Short answer: Choose an SEO company by checking four things: how they work, how openly they report, who owns your accounts, and whether you can start with a small, low-risk step such as an audit. Ask for deliverables and a roadmap rather than ranking promises, because no provider controls what Google shows.
Every SEO company sounds sure of itself on a sales call. That's the problem. The ones who know what they're doing and the ones who don't can use almost the same words.
Imagine two proposals on your desk. One promises "page-one rankings for 20 keywords". The other lists a technical review, a page-by-page optimisation plan, a content calendar and a monthly report, with an owner next to each item. The first is easier to understand. The second is easier to hold someone to, and that matters once the invoices start.
This guide shows you how to tell them apart: what a good provider takes responsibility for, what a fair scope looks like, ten questions to ask, and a scorecard you can copy. We're an SEO company ourselves, so use the scorecard on us too.
What should an SEO company actually be responsible for?
What they can influence
What nobody can promise
What does a fair SEO scope look like?
Technical, content and authority work in one plan
SEO stalls when only one of these gets attention. A brilliant article on a page that can't be indexed earns nothing. A clean site with nothing worth ranking earns nothing either. A fair scope covers all three in order: fix what blocks, improve what exists, then add what's missing.
That's how we build SEO services: a technical audit and fixes, on-page and content work, keyword research and mapping, link building and reporting, all in one prioritised roadmap rather than a menu of separate tasks.
Deliverables you can count
Whatever the provider, you should be able to check the work. Here is what to look for.
Area | Example deliverable | How you can check it |
Technical | An audit with issues ranked by impact, with example URLs | Open the list and spot-check three URLs |
On-page | Titles, headings, copy and internal links updated on named pages | Compare the live pages with the list |
Keywords | A keyword map that gives each target page one main topic | Each page has one clear job (our guide on keyword clustering and mapping explains the idea) |
Content | A set number of briefs and articles per month | Published URLs and dates |
Authority | Links or mentions earned, with sources | A list you can click through |
Reporting | A monthly report covering actions and next steps | It says what was done, what changed and what happens next |
Reporting you can read
Which questions should you ask before you sign?
Use these on a call and write the answers down.
Question | A good answer sounds like | A warning sign |
1. What will you do in the first 30 days? | An audit, access, a baseline and the first fixes | "We'll start optimising" |
2. Who does the work, and who will I speak to? | Named roles | "Our team" |
3. How do you decide what to fix first? | Impact against effort, with reasons | One checklist for every client |
4. Who owns the Search Console, Analytics and website accounts? | You do, with them added as users | They set them up under their own login |
5. How do you measure success if rankings aren't the goal? | Leads, qualified traffic, visibility on key pages | Rankings only |
6. What happens if results are slower than expected? | A review that diagnoses the cause | Silence, or a bigger package |
7. How do you build links? | An explanation of sources and quality, with examples | "A proprietary network" and no detail |
8. Who writes the content, and who checks it is accurate? | Writers plus a review step | Auto-generated text, no review |
9. How long is the contract and how do I leave? | A review point and a clear notice period | A long lock-in with penalties |
10. Can you show similar work? | A case study with context (our case studies are an example) | Big numbers with no context |
How do you read an SEO proposal?
Read it like a contract, not a brochure. Look for four things.
- Named deliverables with quantities and dates. "Content optimisation" is vague. "Updates to 12 named pages in month one" isn't.
- An owner for each item. Some tasks depend on you: access, approvals, developer time. A good proposal says so.
- A price that matches the scope. You should be able to see roughly where the money goes.
- Exit terms. Notice period, what you keep, and what happens to your accounts and content.
A proposal without deliverables is a promise with an invoice attached.
Which red flags should end the conversation?
- Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed dates.
- "Secret" methods they won't explain.
- Your accounts set up under their login.
- Links sold in bulk at a fixed price with no detail on where they come from.
- A price they can't explain.
- Pressure to sign this week.
- Reports you can't verify yourself.
- Large volumes of content with nobody checking it.
Should you start with an audit before a long contract?
Usually, yes. An audit costs less than a retainer and shows both sides what the work really is. You get a ranked list of problems. The provider gets to prove they can read your site, not just talk about theirs.
It also tests how they communicate. Do they explain the findings in plain language? Do they say what they would fix first and why? You can run a first check yourself with the SEO audit tool, then compare it with what a provider tells you.
On contract length, a middle path usually works: an initial term long enough for the work to show up, a review point partway through, and a clear notice period. A very short term can be unfair to both sides because SEO takes time. A long lock-in with no review is a risk for you.
A scorecard you can copy
Score each line from 1 to 5, multiply by the weight and add it up. The maximum is 500. Change the weights to match what matters to you.
Criterion | Weight | Score (1 to 5) |
Method: do they explain how they work? | 20 | |
Deliverables: are they clear and countable? | 20 | |
Reporting and openness | 15 | |
Account ownership and access | 15 | |
Relevant experience | 10 | |
Contract flexibility | 10 | |
Communication | 10 |
Anything under about 350 on this version means more questions or a smaller first step. That line is a rule of thumb, not a standard.
